Technical guide · Non-precious alloys · Mesa Italy since 1975
Alloy Protocol
Guide to the use of alloys and support for troubleshooting and problem solving.
The Guide to Using Mesa Alloys is a technical manual written by a team of Mesa Italia specialists to provide precise information on non-precious alloys and deliver to the operator a correct protocol for dental laboratory work. The manual simplifies processing procedures, analyzes the treatments needed to make the best use of the chosen alloy and summarizes advantages and problems. It is intended both for dental technicians performing traditional work and for those who have adopted digital technologies. Below is the full content of the guide, chapter by chapter.
1. Non-precious alloys
The non-precious alloys MESA are available in the form of mill discs and blocks for lost wax casting. They have high mechanical properties with excellent performance at both room temperature and higher temperatures, and have been formulated to have excellent corrosion resistance. The alloys are divided into categories based on the element present in a higher percentage: Cobalt alloys combined with Chromium, the most used in the dental field, in which the main constituent is Cobalt.
In these alloys, the good mechanical properties mainly depend on the fact that the elements added to cobalt form a solid solution with it, changing its crystalline lattice. The percentage of cobalt varies from 40% to 70% and gives great mechanical strength, hardness and rigidity; the second component is chromium, from 20% to 35%, which confers corrosion resistance thanks to the ability to passivate and form a stable oxide that prevents the progression of oxidation.
The use of Nickel in the dental world is still very widespread, as it has excellent mechanical characteristics and a great resistance to corrosion, with a melting temperature (1455 ° C) lower than Cobalt (1495 ° C).
1.1 Composition and characteristics
Other metals present in smaller amounts in MESA dental superalloys are:
- Carbonio: in low proportions increases hardness and strength; in high quantities makes the alloy harder but also more brittle.
- Molibdeno: in concentrations between 3% and 6% increases mechanical strength and improves corrosion resistance of the pitting type.
- Tungsteno: aumenta la resistenza meccanica.
- Silicio e Manganese: increase the fluidity and therefore the malleability of the alloys.
- Niobio: affina il grano.
1.2 Physical and mechanical properties
Density
The density is obtained by dividing the mass of the body by its volume and is expressed in g/cm3.
Heat conduction
The thermal conductivity of metals is much higher than that of natural teeth: the metal less insulates the tooth from temperature fluctuations and this can cause discomfort to the patient.
Tensile strength and bending strength
The tensile strength is the capacity of a section of the material to withstand a tensile load, expressed in N/mm2. For materials with more variable behavior, the tensile and compressive resistance are evaluated simultaneously through the flexure test. In the dental field, it is very important to consider both: in the case of fixed prostheses with high cantilever, materials with greater resistance to bending must be preferred to avoid fractures of the coating, while materials with less resistance can be chosen for skeletal prostheses.
Other, not further worked than hot-rolled
The elastic modulus, expressed in GPa (103 N/mm2), expresses the rigidity of a material. At the same load, the material with a lower elastic modulus deforms more.
Resilience
Resilience is the ability of a body to absorb shocks without breaking or deforming.[1] Metal materials generally have sufficient resilience for use in the mouth; other materials, such as ceramics, can break from shocks or thermal shocks.
Hardness
Hardness measures the ability of a material to resist penetration by another body. The reference test in dentistry is Vickers hardness, which measures the sinking of a diamond tip pressed with known force on the flat surface of the material.
Wear and tear
Wear occurs when two materials move relative to each other generating friction, with decreased size of the bodies in contact. It depends on the hardness of the materials, grain size, surface roughness, interposed fluids and other factors. In the dental field it affects the maintenance of the vertical size and occlusal surface: the occlusion surfaces must be treated to be as shiny as possible.
1.3 Management and modelling of metal structures
In the construction of a fixed prosthesis (crown and bridges) the supporting structure (framework) in metallic material must provide a precise anatomical drawing. Starting from the final shape of the dental elements, a part of the material is removed to ensure the thicknesses useful to restore aesthetics and function. The substructure must be sub-dimensioned to ensure the appropriate thickness of the aesthetic material, both in metal-ceramic and metal-composite.
The main passages:
- To correctly shape the anatomical tooth.
- Reduce the design to create a proper structure.
- Make a mathematical reduction only with the CAD function: a loss of support in the incisional area increases the risk of chipping of the ceramic.
- The minimum thickness of the metal substrate shall always be checked, both in analogue and digital form.
The modelling must be carried out taking into account the production methodology: in milling, factors such as the diameter of the mills and the angles reachable by the milling machine determine the congruences between CAD design and CAM production.
When working on dental implants, it is important to consider:
- the reliability and stability of the shape and diameter of the implant connection;
- the stability of the clamping screw, which may have different performance depending on the design;
- the length of the transmucosal pathway;
- the diameter and any inclination of the screw channel.
Depending on the position of the elements, it is essential to evaluate the directions of loads: in the rear areas the forces are mainly vertical, in the front areas mainly transverse; the interdental connectors must be oriented in the direction of the forces to ensure maximum support to the structure.
The use of the distal cantilever is always risky and should be limited to cases of absolute necessity: the lack of a distal support element must be compensated by a connector of high diameter.
Casting
Fusion is the oldest process of metalworking and, although it may seem old-fashioned, it remains a very effective and precise system.
2.1 Preparation for the merger
The coating most commonly used for the superalloys in Cr-Co MESA is a phosphate binder, consisting mainly of Quartz, which confers hardness, and Cristobalite, which being a ceramic material makes the surfaces of the fuses smoother.
2.2 Casting
The following fusion techniques may be used:
- Flame melting (cinnamon)
- For the purposes of headings 8402 to 8404
- Manufacture in which the value of all the materials used does not exceed 30% of the ex-works price of the product
For cannel smelting, it is important to use a mixture of propane at 0.7 bar and oxygen at 2 bar, in a ceramic crucible. It is essential not to use graphite crucibles, which could release carbon by changing the properties of the alloy and releasing gas during the ceramization, creating bubbles in the ceramics or reduced adhesion with consequent change in the color of the artifact. At first the alloy blocks agglomerate and form a completely non-liquid single body: when the surface crust opens, the casting takes place.
2.3 Alloys for casting
The following characteristics are common to all Mesa ceramic alloys:
- manufactured in accordance with ISO 9693 and ISO 22674;
- strictly free of toxic elements: beryllium, cadmium, lead, indium and gallium;
- universal use: bridges and crowns, double crowns, superstructures on implants, bonding technique, secondary parts in combined prostheses;
- a coefficient of thermal expansion between (25 ÷ 500 °C) 14,1 × 10−6 K−1 and (25 ÷ 600 °C) 14,6 × 10−6 K−1: perfectly ceramic;
- high degree of purity;
- high corrosion and heat resistance.
The most popular ceramic Mesa alloys on the market areMAGNUM LUCENS, I ‘m not going to lie to you . e MAGNUM CERAMIC Co.
MAGNUM LUCENS Tipo 4
Composition
| Copper and articles thereof; except for: | 63% |
|---|---|
| Manufacture from materials of any heading, except that of the product | 28% |
| Other, of circular cross-section, of iron or steel | 4% |
| Other, of circular cross-section, of iron or steel | 3% |
| Other | Mn, Fe |
Physical and mechanical properties
| The temperature of solids and liquids | 1253 ÷ 1304 °C |
|---|---|
| Point of fusion | 1360 °C |
| Density | Of a thickness not exceeding 1 mm |
| Vickers hardness | 324 HV10 |
| Breaking length | 3% |
| Unit of stress load (Rp0.2) | Other, of circular cross-section |
| Modulus of elasticity | Manufacture in which the value of all the materials used does not exceed 30% of the ex-works price of the product |
| Ion release in 7 days | 0,8 μg/cm2 |
| Maximum boiling point | 980 °C |
| Colour | White |
| Coefficient of thermal expansion (25 ÷ 500 °C) | 14,1 × 10⁻⁶ K⁻¹ |
| Coefficient of thermal expansion (25 ÷ 600 °C) | 14,5 × 10⁻⁶ K⁻¹ |
MAGNUM SPLENDIDUM Tipo 3
Composition
| Copper and articles thereof; except for: | 61% |
|---|---|
| Manufacture from materials of any heading, except that of the product | 28% |
| Other, of circular cross-section, of iron or steel | 1,5% |
| Other, of circular cross-section, of iron or steel | 8,5% |
| Other | Mn, Fe |
Physical and mechanical properties
| The temperature of solids and liquids | 1308 ÷ 1384 °C |
|---|---|
| Point of fusion | 1440 °C |
| Density | Of a thickness not exceeding 6 mm |
| Vickers hardness | 273 HV10 |
| Breaking length | 16% |
| Unit of stress load (Rp0.2) | 360 MPa |
| Modulus of elasticity | Manufacture in which the value of all the materials used does not exceed 30% of the ex-works price of the product |
| Ion release in 7 days | 1,75 μg/cm2 |
| Maximum boiling point | 980 °C |
| Colour | White |
| Coefficient of thermal expansion (25 ÷ 500 °C) | 14,2 × 10⁻⁶ K⁻¹ |
| Coefficient of thermal expansion (25 ÷ 600 °C) | 14,4 × 10⁻⁶ K⁻¹ |
MAGNUM CERAMIC Co Tipo 5
Composition
| Copper and articles thereof; except for: | 64% |
|---|---|
| Manufacture from materials of any heading, except that of the product | 21% |
| Manufacture from materials of any heading, except that of the product | 6% |
| Other, of circular cross-section, of iron or steel | 6% |
| Other | Yes, Mn, Fe |
Physical and mechanical properties
| The temperature of solids and liquids | 1309 ÷ 1417 °C |
|---|---|
| Point of fusion | 1470 °C |
| Density | Of a thickness not exceeding 1 mm |
| Vickers hardness | 286 HV10 |
| Breaking length | 10% |
| Unit of stress load (Rp0.2) | 570 MPa |
| Modulus of elasticity | Manufacture in which the value of all the materials used does not exceed 30% of the ex-works price of the product |
| Ion release in 7 days | 0,6 μg/cm2 |
| Maximum boiling point | 935 °C |
| Colour | White |
| Coefficient of thermal expansion (25 ÷ 500 °C) | 14,1 × 10⁻⁶ K⁻¹ |
| Coefficient of thermal expansion (25 ÷ 600 °C) | 14,6 × 10⁻⁶ K⁻¹ |
Strengths of each alloy:
- MAGNUM LUCENS: in the melting process it is a very slippery alloy with very pleasant oxidation; for its high stability it is recommended for very extensive prostheses (circular, bar, Toronto).
- I ‘m not going to lie to you .: the strength is high workability, with a Vickers hardness of 273 HV10.
- MAGNUM CERAMIC Co: historic company league, a guarantee in the process of ceramising.
Other, of circular cross-section, of iron or steel
The alloys for skeletons produced by Mesa are characterized by high tensile strength and excellent workability, which allow smooth and compact surfaces with reduced oxide formation, and by excellent mechanical properties that allow even the most demanding technicians to create unique products of thin thickness.MAGNUM VIP-A e MAGNUM HBA.
MAGNUM VIP-A Tipo 5
Composition
| Copper and articles thereof; except for: | 64% |
|---|---|
| Manufacture from materials of any heading, except that of the product | 29% |
| Manufacture from materials of any heading, except that of the product | 6% |
| Other | C, Si, Mn, Fe |
Physical and mechanical properties
| The temperature of solids and liquids | 1350 ÷ 1406 °C |
|---|---|
| Point of fusion | 1460 °C |
| Density | Of a thickness not exceeding 1 mm |
| Vickers hardness | 386 HV10 |
| Breaking length | 6% |
| Unit of stress load (Rp0.2) | 580 MPa |
| Modulus of elasticity | Manufacture in which the value of all the materials used does not exceed 30% of the ex-works price of the product |
| Ion release in 7 days | 1,1-μg/cm2 and |
| Colour | White |
MAGNUM HBA Tipo 5
Composition
| Copper and articles thereof; except for: | 62% |
|---|---|
| Manufacture from materials of any heading, except that of the product | 31% |
| Manufacture from materials of any heading, except that of the product | 5% |
| Other | C, Si, Mn, Fe |
Physical and mechanical properties
| The temperature of solids and liquids | 1340 ÷ 1400 °C |
|---|---|
| Point of fusion | 1450 °C |
| Density | Of a thickness not exceeding 6 mm |
| Vickers hardness | 389 HV10 |
| Breaking length | 6% |
| Unit of stress load (Rp0.2) | 610 MPa |
| Modulus of elasticity | 200 GPa |
| Ion release in 7 days | 0,49 μg/cm2 |
| Maximum boiling point | 980 °C |
| Colour | White |
2.4 Overmelting
The technique of superfusion allows for the creation of crowns that are bolted on to implants. Initially, the implants were made using completely calcifiable plastic components, but these were not very accurate, and were not recommended for implants with superfusable components.
The problems associated with this type of element may be:
- the diameter of the screw hole shall be determined by the expansion of the coating and may need to be bolted in;
- the presence of small bubbles in the screw channel, to be removed manually, due to the casting of the coating in a narrow space;
- possible residues of the calcinable not completely eliminated at the point of interconnection between the two metals, which being very small may alter the precision of the article.
Using a completely overlapping Mesa metal componentry, the above problems are solved and excellent and easily repeatable results are obtained. MESA has made in Magnum Splendidum alloy overlapping components compatible with the metal recommended for the overlapping Magnum Lucens which, thanks to its physical and chemical characteristics, allows to obtain a real welding between the two components without deforming the connection.
Measures for proper over-fusion:
- extend the cylinder preheating time by at least 50% over the standard;
- not exceed 1410 °C during melting;
- The thermal expansion coefficient (CET) of ceramics must be between 5% and 10% lower than that of metal.
2.5 Overlapping table in Cr-Co
Overcastable Mesa, characterized by an optimal precision in the engagement with the plant, have peculiar advantages determined by the absence of the traditional moulding cannula in calcinable plastic.
The oversized Mesa:
- replace the conventional coupling system constructed of calcinable plastic;
- be compatible with the main implant systems;
- are available in rotary and non-rotary versions;
- allow single crowns or multiple screwed structures to be made.
The overcastable mesas are characterised by:
- Percorso vite indeformabile: the inner part remains unchanged from the casting and the screws fit perfectly inside the hole.
- Melting without impurities in the screw channel: absence of possible combustion residues from the melting of the calcinable plastic, resulting in improved surface.
- Optimal welding between the two metals: the perfect coupling between the two Magnum Splendidum and Magnum Lucens alloys during the melting process results in an optimal adhesion and guarantees maximum precision in the welding, while preventing the two metals from detaching.
3. Milling of metal alloys for dentistry
3.1 General advice on milling strategy
The four basic shapes of the tools used are: toric milling, spherical milling, cylindrical milling and drilling tip.
- Toric burs: they excel in the operation of roughing and mass removal of material.
- Ball-nose burs: used in finishing processes (sometimes also in roughing).
- Cylindrical burs: used almost exclusively for the creation of features with faces perpendicular to each other, where it is necessary to reproduce a net angle between a plane and a wall, primarily in the case of implant connection geometries to ensure the perfect adaptability of prosthetic components.
- Punte da perforazione: Highly efficient tools for making holes, used to speed up the making of screw holes and threaded holes.
These four shapes are accompanied by other shapes that are used less frequently, with limited application to specific processes: threaded mills, T-mills, lollipop mills, centrifuges or cyanophores.
The speed of rotation and advance of the milling machine responds to a mathematical rule that takes into account many factors: the type of milling material, the material to be milled, the sinking of the milling machine into the material, the number of cutters and the surface treatment that can profoundly alter the performance.
The smaller the diameter of a milling machine, the higher the need for the spindle to rotate: the spindles of CNC milling machines have low torques but very high rotation speed, sometimes over 60,000 turns per minute.
3.2 Minimum thicknesses, fragile parts
Although a milling machine has no difficulty in meeting very narrow dimensional tolerances, the metal materials of dental CAD/CAM have outstanding elasticity and ductility, which translate into deformability. Excessively long and thin areas of the file to be milled (orientally over 5 mm of protrusion and below 0.3 mm thick) can react to cutting by “evading” the milling machine, bending rather than letting themselves be cut. Thin edges, very protruding margin lines or not properly supported screw channels can be pushed and moved by the milling machine.
A good rule of thumb is to avoid modelling files with areas thinner than 0.3 mm or particularly protruding edges; if anatomy makes very protruding edges indispensable, it is necessary to compensate by increasing their thickness at the margin lines.
Another factor is the maximum resolution achievable in production, which depends on the choice of tools: pockets, narrow areas and very small interdental spaces are reproducible only if at least one milling machine has access to these areas.
It is also necessary to take into account the ability of the numerical control milling machine to reach areas of the file “hidden” from sub-frames, even by working with 5 axes.
3.3 Parameters for the milling of Mesa alloys
The parameters to be set are the number of revolutions per minute of the milling machine (S, in rpm) and the rate of advance (F, in mm/min). The milling machine manufacturers do not provide these parameters but other characteristics, so it is necessary to calculate them with formulas.
Recommended cutting speedsfor MESA milling alloys with coated hard metal milling machines (it is however recommended to use the milling machine manufacturer’s parameters where available):
| Other medicinal products not elsewhere specified or included | Vc 55 to 70 m/min |
|---|---|
| Other, not further worked than hot-rolled | Vc 55 to 70 m/min |
| I ‘m not going to lie to you . | Vc 45 to 55 m/min |
In milling, it is always recommended to irrigate with a lubricant consisting of a water-oil emulsion with a quantity of oil greater than 10% by volume; a lower percentage significantly reduces the life of the mills. If the high percentage of oil creates foam problems, antifoam products can be used.
3.4 CAD/CAM discs
Mesa produces discs for CAD/CAM machining in Chromium-Cobalt and Titanium, in the following heights: 8, 10, 12, 13, 5, 14, 15, 16, 18, 20, 22, 24, 5 and 25 mm, with a diameter of 98, 5 mm.
The Chromium-Cobalt Mesa discs, which have been on the market for almost 20 years, are produced with Magnum Splendidum and Magnum Solaree alloys and are characterised by an easier milling process that results in greater consistency in the precision of the prototyped piece.
MAGNUM SPLENDIDUM (disco) Tipo 3
Composition
| Copper and articles thereof; except for: | 61% |
|---|---|
| Manufacture from materials of any heading, except that of the product | 28% |
| Other, of circular cross-section, of iron or steel | 1,5% |
| Other, of circular cross-section, of iron or steel | 8,5% |
| Other | Mn, Fe |
Physical and mechanical properties
| The temperature of solids and liquids | 1308 ÷ 1384 °C |
|---|---|
| Point of fusion | 1440 °C |
| Density | Of a thickness not exceeding 6 mm |
| Vickers hardness | 273 HV10 |
| Breaking length | 16% |
| Unit of stress load (Rp0.2) | 360 MPa |
| Modulus of elasticity | Manufacture in which the value of all the materials used does not exceed 30% of the ex-works price of the product |
| Ion release in 7 days | 1,75 μg/cm2 |
| Maximum boiling point | 980 °C |
| Colour | White |
| Coefficient of thermal expansion (25 ÷ 500 °C) | 14,2 × 10⁻⁶ K⁻¹ |
| Coefficient of thermal expansion (25 ÷ 600 °C) | 14,4 × 10⁻⁶ K⁻¹ |
MAGNUM SOLARE (disco) Tipo 4
Composition
| Copper and articles thereof; except for: | 66% |
|---|---|
| Manufacture from materials of any heading, except that of the product | 27% |
| Manufacture from materials of any heading, except that of the product | 6% |
| Other | Yes, of course. |
Physical and mechanical properties
| The temperature of solids and liquids | 1307 ÷ 1417 °C |
|---|---|
| Point of fusion | 1470 °C |
| Density | Of a thickness not exceeding 1 mm |
| Vickers hardness | 255 HV10 |
| Breaking length | 11% |
| Unit of stress load (Rp0.2) | Manufacture in which the value of all the materials used does not exceed 30% of the ex-works price of the product |
| Modulus of elasticity | 233 GPa |
| Maximum boiling point | 980 °C |
| Colour | White |
| Coefficient of thermal expansion (25 ÷ 500 °C) | 14,3 × 10⁻⁶ K⁻¹ |
| Coefficient of thermal expansion (25 ÷ 600 °C) | 14,5 × 10⁻⁶ K⁻¹ |
Titanium Mesa discs are manufactured with Magnum Hyperone alloy in titanium grade 23.
MAGNUM HYPERONE (disco Ti) Tipo 4
Composition
| Titanium (Ti) | 90% |
|---|---|
| Aluminium (Al) | 6% |
| Other, of circular cross-section, of iron or steel | 4% |
| Other | Fe |
Physical and mechanical properties
| The temperature of solids and liquids | 1605 ÷ 1660 °C |
|---|---|
| Point of fusion | 1710 °C |
| Density | Manufacture from materials of any heading, except that of the product |
| Vickers hardness | 312 HV10 |
| Breaking length | 14% |
| Unit of stress load (Rp0.2) | 880 MPa |
| Modulus of elasticity | Manufacture in which the value of all the materials used does not exceed 40% of the ex-works price of the product |
| Colour | White |
Titanium discs are characterised by being highly biocompatible, corrosion resistant, lightweight, easy to mill and very tough.
3.5 Protocol for the preparation and use of Magnum Solare
Stage 1: thermal expansion
Parameters: 1030 °C for 7 minutes (1 to 3 elements); 1030 °C for 12 minutes (more than 3 elements).
Cobalt-chromium heat treatment is aimed at distension, an essential process to eliminate the remaining tensile and compressive forces in the metal structure after processing. The treatment brings the products to a temperature at which the material has a very low release load; at this temperature the residual stresses are reduced thanks to micro-viscous scarring of the material until they become negligible. It is essential for maintaining geometric stability during subsequent processing and for increasing fatigue resistance, reducing the risk of crack propagation.
Stage 2: oxidation
Parametri: 980 °C per 2 minuti.
Oxidation is a natural phenomenon that occurs when a metal combines with oxygen to form a surface oxide. It is essential in dentistry because it improves the adhesion between the ceramic and the metal alloy and optimizes the application phase of the opaque wash and the opaque layer.
Stage 3: Lamination of ceramics
Dental ceramics are divided into feldspar ceramics (mixtures based on feldspar) and synthetic ceramics.
- Having a coefficient of thermal expansion compatible with the metal (CET: 14,3 × 10−6 K−1);
- do not use bonding;
- mix the opaque paste with a drop of distilled water to dilute and improve its consistency and to allow it to dry earlier (use of opaque powder is recommended).
This protocol is specific to Mesa Magnum Solare discs (CET: 14.3 × 10−6 K−1).
Stage 4 – cooling
Parametri: 450 °C, apertura del forno e raffreddamento graduale.
After the ceramic has been baked, the artifact must be cooled slowly and gradually to room temperature to ensure structural stability and metal properties (hardness, strength), preventing defects. A gradual cooling process avoids internal stresses in the alloy, reduces the risk of ceramic fractures and stabilizes the mechanical properties of the artifact.
Conclusions:Magnum Solare is a Medical Device manufactured by Mesa Italia S.r.l. For any doubt or need always refer to the Instructions for Use (IFU) of the Medical Device or contact the qualified staff of Mesa Italia S.r.l.
4. The adhesion of aesthetic materials
The framework is the skeletal part of the prosthetic rehabilitation and provides the artifact with support and rigidity, whether the prosthetic rests on natural teeth or on implants.
Adhesion (connection between two surfaces) refers to the force that opposes the separation of two bodies placed in contact.
4.1 Mechanical adhesion
The type of sand varies depending on the aesthetic material to be used. There are synthetic glass microspheres to polish the surfaces, ideal for attacks and contusions, with granulometry from 55 to 100 microns. Aluminum oxide is used for cleaning coating residues from metals and for preparing the surface for a mechanical adhesion: it must always be used in households to produce a pure metal composite, the granulometry is indicated from 90 to 110 microns;
4.2 Chemical adhesion
Composite manufacturers provide a liquid metal primer in the set, mostly consisting of hydrophobic phosphate monomers or sulfur derivatives, which create a direct chemical adhesion between the metal and the opaque composite.
4.3 Non-heat treatments
It is recommended to finish the structures using tungsten and silicon carbide milling machines.Pre-oxidation cleaning is carried out by sandblasting with aluminium oxide with a particle size of 90 to 110 microns and subsequent cleaning by vaporization.
4.4 Heat treatments
It is extremely important to heat treat the metals, whether molten or milled, although for different reasons, before proceeding to the aesthetic finishing of the manufacture. For molten metals heat treatment is necessary to homogenise the crystal structure of the material that has undergone a change of solid/liquid/solid state, achieving a chemical and microstructural balance, eliminating the damaging phases in the recently cooled alloys, including the gases incorporated during the melting, and reducing the stresses created by cooling.
To achieve an effective treatment, it is recommended to reach a temperature between 50 and 80 degrees above the oxidation temperature and maintain it for 7-12 minutes in the atmosphere.
4.5 Aesthetic finish
A fundamental parameter is the compatibility between the CET (coefficient of thermal expansion) of the metal and that of the ceramic: the CET of the ceramic must be lower than that of the metal, in a range between 5% and 10%. All ceramics that fall within these parameters are suitable for use with these alloys.
5. Problems and solutions
5.1 Porosity
- With cannel melting, the incorrect adjustment of the propane/oxygen ratio may result in circular porosities on the melting surface, due to gas intrusions of the liquid alloy: adjust the pressure of propane to 1 bar and of oxygen to 2-3 bar.
- The solidification of the alloy in the casting channel before it enters the anatomical part may result in porosity: increase the diameter of the casting channel; add a small amount of alloy to have a good maturing that keeps the temperature of the alloy in the channel high; use a diameter reserve about 25% larger than the inlet zone.
- An incongruous relationship between the model and the reserves or the incorrect placement of the casting channel can be a further cause: placing the casting channel in the corresponding thickest part.
5.2 Surface roughness
- The excessive amount of total mixing liquid can result in a rough surface, as it makes the coating more porous and brittle.
- Excessive push or pressure during casting of the alloy.
- Excessive temperature of the alloy itself.
Carefully follow the manufacturer’s instructions for use of the coating.
5.3 Missing parts
To avoid factors that may cause reduced thrust, insufficient machine pressure or poor alloy heating:
- carefully adjust the pressure or thrust of the die;
- check the flame position and the correct casting temperature;
- avoid short or insufficient cylinder preheating: adjust preheating times in relation to cylinder size;
- to avoid incomplete calcination of the mould: use materials that do not leave residues; weigh the complete mould of casting pins and multiply the value by the specific weight of the metal.
5.4 Alloy coating residues
- Presence of edges in the modelling.
- Mismatch between the molding and the casting pins.
- Impurity of any reused alloy.
Careful care should be taken with the finishing of the joint between the casting pins and the moulding to avoid edges and clogs; if part of an already molten alloy is reused, the part should be thoroughly cleaned.
5.5 Difficulty in polishing metal
- Porous metal.
- Incorrect polishing protocol: follow the correct polishing protocols.
5.6 Spotted oxidation
- Possible contamination during finishing: use milling machines dedicated exclusively to each type of metal.
5.7 Incomplete adhesion of the coarse metal
- The coated metal does not flow completely to the defined margin of the coating: check the temperature and the preheating time of the cylinder and the thickness of the coated part.
5.8 Fractures
- Fratture verticali: can be generated by incompatibility between the metal and ceramic CETs or by incorrect cooling in proportion to the quantity of metal.
- Fratture orizzontali: often generated by a lack of support for the substructure (see structure modelling, section 1.3).
- Chipping: incorrect CET, angular substructure, parafunctions of the patient, incorrect anatomy of the modelling, bending of the structure for failure to respect minimum thicknesses.
5.9 Removal of ceramics, bubbles and other articles
- Use of inadequate crucibles (graphite or contaminated).
- First layer of opaque too dense.
- Excessive use of opaque fluid.
Make opaque layers not too dense by reactivating the material with distilled water; use dedicated crucibles and change them as needed; take care not to burn the alloy by checking temperatures; respect the parameters indicated by the house for oxidation.
Appendix – Bur contamination in cobalt-chromium finishing
Technical study Mesa Italia: chemical and physical mechanism of titanium contamination during the finishing of CoCr alloys, effects on ceramic stratification, laboratory operating protocol and risk summary table.
1. Introduction and framing of the problem
In the modern dental laboratory, cobalt-chromium (Co-Cr) alloy, worked by CAD/CAM milling or casting, is the backbone of ceramicizable prosthetic structures. However, the manual finishing phase at the handpiece – often considered a simple routine procedure – hides an insidious enemy: cross-contamination of the metal surface (Cross-Contamination).
Using on the cobalt-chromium structure rotary instruments (tungsten carbide burs, diamond instruments or polishing rubber points) previously used on titanium or on other heterogeneous alloys irreparably damages the surface of the base metal, affecting the adhesion and final quality of the ceramic stratification.
The chemical and physical mechanism of titanium contamination
To understand the reason for the failure of ceramization, we need to analyze what happens at the microscopic level when a “polluted” milling machine comes into contact with Cobalt-Chromium:
- Transfer of micro-particles:During chip removal or sanding, the titanium micro-slabs deposited between the blades or in the diamond grains of the milling machine “spread out” and get embedded by mechanical friction on the surface of the Cobalt-Chromium.
- Incompatibility of the coefficient of thermal expansion (CET):Cobalt-Chromium for ceramics has a CET of about 14.1 and Titanium is around 9.6 and Titanium micro-inclusions create local points of very high thermal stress during cooling cycles in the ceramic furnace.
- Ossidazione anomala e iper-ossidazione:Titanium has a much higher affinity for oxygen than cobalt and chromium. During the oxidation or cooking phase of the opaque (usually between 900 and 980 degrees Celsius), the titanium on the surface reacts violently, forming a titanium oxide (TiO₂) film that is thick, brittle and devoid of mechanical strength.
3. Clinical and visual effects on ceramic stratification
When the surface of the metal is contaminated by titanium or by residues from other processes, the ceramising stage shows characteristic defects:
A. Delamination and opacification
The opaque binds chemically to the brittle titanium oxide instead of the correct layer of chromium/cobalt oxide, resulting in the first thermal surge or mechanical stress, the opaque completely “shells” off, exposing the underlying metal.
B. Bubble forming
Trapped organic or foreign metal residues release gas during vacuum cooking of ceramics, causing micro-bubbles in the dentine/glaze coating or pitting visible on the surface after glaze cooking.
C. Dischromes and Chromatic Alones
The non-homogeneous oxide produces unpleasant grey-greenish or dark haloes, especially in the collars and interoximal areas where manual finishing has been more intense.
4. Laboratory operating protocol: how to avoid contamination
In order to ensure perfect and risk-free stratification, strictly follow the following protocol:
- Exclusive use of burs:Use colored rings or separate racks for cobalt-chromium, titanium and Aulique/Noble alloys.
- Choice of milling type:use tungsten carbide cross-sectional finishing mills specifically for hard metals, or diamond mills dedicated to non-noble alloys.
- Correct working pressure:If the metal is pressed too hard, it will absorb debris instead of removing it.
- Single-use, controlled sandblasting:The abrasive must be clean and not recycled from previous sanding of other metals.
- Deep cleaning after finishing:ultrasonic washing of the structure with specific degreasing liquid or isopropyl alcohol, followed by intense vaporization to saturated steam.
- Controllo dell’Ossidazione Calibrata:perform the oxidation cycle according to the instructions of the alloy manufacturer. The surface must be of a uniform colour (light grey to golden/brownish). Any dark or spotty stains indicate contamination and require further sanding and cleaning.
5. Summary table of risks of contamination
| Type of pollutant | Operating cause | Effect on Ceramics |
|---|---|---|
| Titanium (Ti) | Use of milling machines used on Titanium | Hyper-oxidation, opaque scaling off, cracks from CET. |
| Resins / waxes / grease | Manufacture from materials of any heading, except that of the product | Air bubbles, porosity of the surface, pitting, blackening. |
| Corundum Pollution | Recycled sand from other metals | Weak anchorage, colour spots, local micro-stumps. |
6. Conclusions
The final quality of a cobalt-chromium ceramic prosthesis depends equally on CAD/CAM technology, the quality of the alloy and the operational discipline in the finishing stage.
Frequently asked questions on CoCr mill contamination
Why does the opaque break off from the cobalt-chromium structure after cooking?
The main cause is almost never ceramics or metal, but cross-contamination from milling already used on Titanium. The micro-particles of Ti get embedded in CoCr, creating heat stress points (different CET: 14.1-14.7 vs 9.6 ×10⁻⁶ K⁻¹) and hyper-oxidation with formation of brittle TiO₂ to which the opaque binds chemically instead of the correct chromium/cobalt oxide.
Can I use the same cutters for cobalt-chromium and titanium?
Each metal family must have its own unique and coded set of rotating tools (tungsten carbide milling, diamond tools, polishing rubbers).
How to avoid bubbles in ceramics on CoCr milling?
The bubbles come from trapped organic or foreign metal residues that release gas during vacuum cooking. Causes: contaminated milling, manual contact, oil of the maple, recycled corundum. Protocol: dedicated milling, sandblasting with pure corundum 110µm single use, ultrasonic washing + saturated steam.
What grain size and pressure for sandblasting the CoCr?
100% pure aluminium oxide (Corundum) with a particle size of 110 μm at 2.5-3 bar pressure.
How do I know if CoCr is properly oxidized?
The surface must be of a uniform colour (light grey to golden/brownish) and any dark or spotted stains indicate contamination and require further sanding and cleaning before proceeding.
Table Italy
Mesa Italia S.r.l. is an Italian company with a long family tradition, leader in the production of metal alloys in Chromium-Cobalt, founded with the aim of combining tradition, innovation and quality.
- Quality and innovation: the use of the highest quality, carefully selected raw materials and the adoption of the most modern production technologies with strict quality control.
- Produzione 100% factory made: complete assortment of products for the dental laboratory and practice, entirely factory-made and 100% made in Italy.
- Leadership globale: exports to more than 60 countries, with a distribution network covering all continents.
- Reliability and customer service: every stage, from production to shipment, is designed to offer a precise, timely and personalised service.
Autorizzazioni e certificazioni internazionali:strict selection of raw materials to ensure that each product is completely free of Beryllium and Cadmium and free of Nickel in all cobalt-based alloys. Marketing authorisation for the devices from the bodies of the 5 MDSAP countries: FDA (USA), Anvisa (Brazil), MHLW (Japan), Health Canada and TGA (Australia).
Catalogue of dental alloys
For the full range of products, the leaflets and the characteristics of each alloy, see the dental alloy catalogue Mesa Italia.
